The Appellant operates health and fitness clubs and made a claim for £434,880 for overpaid output tax on certain membership income. VAT had been accounted for on all membership subscriptions and the Appellant claimed that part of the payments should have been treated as an exempt supply of credit.
The principal issue was whether there is any supply of credit after the first year of certain memberships. That in turn depends on the contractual terms between the Appellant and the relevant members.
It was agreed that in the first year of membership the contract made it clear that those paying in monthly instalment, rather than a lump sum, paid an extra amount for credit. The Tribunal paid particular attention to the contractual terms.
The principal issue concerned what happened at the end of the minimum 12-month period of membership. Those who had paid by lump sum where offered
Subscribe to the McLaughlin’s Tax Case Library to get instant access
to the Tax Case Library.
14 day free trial
, 90 day money back guarantee
Subscribe