This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. To find out more about cookies on this website and how to delete cookies, see our privacy notice.

First-tier Tribunal made an error of law in concluding that the appellants’ conduct was deliberate

By Mark McLaughlin, October 2024

The Upper Tribunal held that the First-tier Tribunal used flawed objective reasoning when deciding that the conduct of the appellants was deliberate in submitting inaccurate tax returns relating to losses generated by a tax avoidance scheme found to be ineffective. 

The appellants appealed to the Upper Tribunal (UT) against a decision of the First-tier Tribunal (FTT) that there was a deliberate inaccuracy in their self-assessment returns for 2005/06, in which they had claimed losses as self-employed options traders. By the time of the appeal hearing before the FTT, the appellants accepted that they were not entitled to the claimed losses. The only issue to be decided by the FTT was whether the extended time limit applied for HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) to issue discovery assessments, which required HMRC to establish that the loss of tax etc., was brought about deliberately. The FTT dismissed the appellants’ appeals. The appellants appealed. 

Subscribe to the McLaughlin’s Tax Case Library to get instant access
to the Tax Case Library.
14 day free trial , 90 day money back guarantee
Subscribe

Related or similar articles

Share loss carry back claim successful but trade loss carry-back claims failed
By Mark McLaughlin, April 2026
HMRC’s refusal to suspend penalty for a careless tax return error was not flawed
By Mark McLaughlin, March 2026
Information and documents not reasonably required and HMRC directed to close the enquiry
By Mark McLaughlin, December 2022
Taxpayer did not deliberately withhold information in failing to file tax returns
By Mark McLaughlin, February 2021
Illness and death of agent’s father was reasonable excuse for taxpayers’ late returns
By Mark McLaughlin, December 2020