This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. To find out more about cookies on this website and how to delete cookies, see our privacy notice.

Identifiable elements of unfair dismissal claim were non-taxable

By Mark McLaughlin, January 2025

Part of an HMRC amendment to the taxpayer’s tax return relating to elements of a claim for unfair dismissal against their former employer was overstated, and the taxpayer’s appeal was allowed in part. 

The appellant was employed on terms which paid them a base salary of [£A] plus a discretionary year end cash bonus and discretionary deferred compensation under a long-term incentive plan (LTIP). The appellant’s discretionary cash bonus [$B] was guaranteed for the first year of employment, but any future bonuses would be determined by reference to a non-exhaustive list of factors. The terms of the LTIP provided the basis on which equity vested. The involuntary termination of employment resulted in the immediate cancellation of any unvested equity-based awards unless the employer applied ‘involuntary termination not involving any cancellation event’ at its discretion. 

On 31 December 2011, the appellant was

Subscribe to the McLaughlin’s Tax Case Library to get instant access
to the Tax Case Library.
14 day free trial , 90 day money back guarantee
Subscribe

Related or similar articles

Licence fees were not ‘income’ following the application of the Ramsay principle
By Mark McLaughlin, June 2025
LLPs were not entitled to EZAs on relevant interests in buildings
By Mark McLaughlin, January 2025
The First-tier Tribunal made errors of law in deciding that IR35 did not apply
By Mark McLaughlin, July 2024
Tribunal refused HMRC's application for appellant's appeal to be struck out
By Mark McLaughlin, May 2021
Mistaken belief about requirement to submit CIS returns was not a reasonably held belief
By Mark McLaughlin, May 2020